11Uriah said to David, “The ark and Israel and Judah remain in booths, and my lord Joab and the servants of my lord are camping in the open field; shall I then go to my house to eat and to drink and to lie with my wife? As you live and as your soul lives, I will not do such a thing.”
The Hebrew, Greek, and Latin that is translated as “soul” in English is translated in Chol with a term that refers to the invisible aspects of human beings (source: Robert Bascom), in Yagaria with oune or “shadow, reflection” (source: Renck, p. 81), and in Elhomwe as “heart” (source: project-specific translation notes in Paratext).
The Mandarin Chineselínghún (靈魂 / 灵魂), literally “spirit-soul,” is often used for “soul” (along with xīn [心] or “heart”). This is a term that was adopted from Buddhist sources into early Catholic writings and later also by Protestant translators. (Source: Zetzsche 1996, p. 32, see also Clara Ho-yan Chan in this article )
In Chichewa, moyo means both “soul” and “life.” (Source: Mawu a Mulungu mu Chichewa Chalero Back Translation)
Some translations specifically reproduce the voice of the Hebrew text of the Old Testament / Hebrew Bible.
English: Uriyya said to David:
The Coffer and Israel and Judah are staying at Sukkot,
my lord Yoav and my lord’s servants are camping on the surface of the open-field —
and I, I should come into my house
to eat and to drink and to lie with my wife?
By your life and by your [very] self: If I were to do this thing . . . !
Source: Everett Fox 2014
German: Urija sprach zu Dawid:
In Hütten weilen der Schrein und Jissrael und Jehuda,
auf der Fläche des Feldes sind mein Herr Joab und meines Herrn Diener gebettet,
und ich, ich sollte in mein Haus kommen, zu essen, zu trinken, bei meinem Weib zu liegen!
sowahr du lebst, sowahr deine Seele lebt: täte ich diese Sache, . . .!
Source: Buber / Rosenzweig 1976
French: Ouryah dit à David:
« Le coffre, Israël et Iehouda habitent des cabanes.
Mon Adôn, Ioab, et les serviteurs de mon Adôn
campent sur les faces du champ. Et moi, je viendrais dans ma maison,
pour boire, pour manger et pour coucher avec ma femme ?
Par ta vie, par la vie de ton être, je ne ferai pas un tel propos. »
Source: Chouraqui 1985
For other verses or sections translated with a Hebraic voice, see here.
The name that is transliterated as “Judah” or “Judea” in English (referring to the son of Jacob, the tribe, and the territory) is translated in Spanish Sign Language as “lion” (referring to Genesis 49:9 and Revelation 5:5). This sign for lion is reserved for regions and kingdoms. (Source: John Elwode in The Bible Translator 2008, p. 78ff. and Steve Parkhurst)
Following are a number of back-translations as well as a sample translation for translators of 2 Samuel 11:11:
Kupsabiny: “Then Uriah replied David, ‘Would I be able to go to my home and eat and drink and sleep with my wife? But the Box of Covenant is there, and Joab and his leaders are there together with all the soldiers of Israel and of Judah in (a) tent. Surely, I am unable to do such a thing.’” (Source: Kupsabiny Back Translation)
Newari: “Uriah replied, "Israel, Judah, and the Ark are in tents, and my master Joab and you my master’s men also setting up tents in the open field. Will I [be the] only [one] to eat and drink and go home to sleep with my wife? I swear by the name of your life, I could never do [a thing] like that."” (Source: Newari Back Translation)
Hiligaynon: “Uria said, ‘The Box of the Covenant and the soldiers of Israel and Juda are-there at the camp in the valley, and there also our (excl.) commander Joab and his officers. Can- I -bear/endure to go-home to eat, drink, and lie-down/(have-sexual-relation) with my wife? I swear to you that I will- not -do that.’” (Source: Hiligaynon Back Translation)
English: “Uriah replied, ‘The soldiers of Judah and Israel are camping in the open fields, and even our commander Joab is sleeping in a tent, and the sacred chest is with them. How could I/It would not be right for me to go home, eat and drink, and sleep with my wife. I solemnly declare that I will never do such a thing!’” (Source: Translation for Translators)
Said: in the context of the conversation between the two men, this may be better translated “responded” (Bible en français courant) or “answered” (Good News Translation) in many languages.
The ark and Israel and Judah: while the Hebrew makes these three nouns the subject of a single verb, it may not be natural to do so in other languages. Israel and Judah go together very well, and this, of course, refers to the soldiers of Israel and Judah who were away at war, and does not refer to civilians, as some have argued. They had taken The ark with them into battle to ensure that the LORD would save them from their enemies (compare Josh 6.6; 1 Sam 4.3). But in many languages a different verb may be required for the Covenant Box. A possible model is “the soldiers of Israel and Judah have left home to fight, and the Covenant Box is with them on the battlefield.”
Dwell in booths: this expression may be seen as having virtually the same meaning as are camping in the open field. The idea is that of living in temporary quarters or nonpermanent dwellings. New Jerusalem Bible has “are lodged in huts.” Others have speculated that perhaps there were reserve troops being housed in huts, while those on the front lines had even less protection from the elements. This idea is given some support by the fact that additional forces led by David himself are in fact called in to finish off the Ammonite capital in 12.28. That booths or temporary dwellings were used in military campaigns is shown in 1 Kgs 20.12-16, so it is probably best to retain this idea in translation. However, Anchor Bible takes the word translated booths as a name meaning “Succoth”: “The ark and Israel and Judah are staying in Succoth.” The Anchor Bible translation eliminates the difficulty of having soldiers sleep in booths rather than tents, but it introduces a more serious problem: Succoth is located around forty kilometers (about twenty-five miles) northwest of Rabbah.
My lord Joab and the servants of my lord: Joab and his officers were, of course, a part of Israel and Judah already mentioned, but the repetition with added detail is a way of making the statement more emphatic. The two occurrences of the words my lord may refer to two different people. The first is clearly stated as Joab, and the second (either King David, as in verse 13, or Joab) is only implied. Since Uriah is addressing David directly, it may be better to say “General Joab and your [other] officers” (Bible en français courant). Good News Translation, on the other hand, takes both as referring to Joab and therefore translates “my commander Joab and his officers.” Either way, the meaning remains practically the same.
Shall I then go to my house? This question is an emphatic way of saying “I cannot possibly go to my house!” In the light of the facts that Uriah has just cited, he felt obligated to refuse the joys of food and drink and sex in his own home. The understanding of Deut 23.9-14 required that military men give up these pleasures in time of war in order to preserve their strength for battle and in order to remain ritually pure (see also 1 Sam 21.5-6).
Lie with my wife: see verse 4 and 1 Sam 2.22.
As you live: instead of the words As you live, a couple of manuscripts of the Septuagint read “as the LORD lives,” which is found frequently elsewhere as an oath. In light of the context the words As you live also seem repetitious. The expression as your soul lives is found together with “as YHWH lives” (see, for example, 1 Sam 20.3; 25.26). New Jerusalem Bible therefore translates “as Yahweh lives and as you yourself live….” Other versions adopting this solution are New American Bible, Moffatt, An American Translation, Osty-Trinquet, and Anderson. This solution has considerable appeal, and translators can not be faulted if they decide to follow it. The Good News Translation rendering “I swear” seems weak whichever solution is adopted. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament, however, gives a {B} rating to the Masoretic Text and suggests that the repetition is intended to underline Uriah’s complete devotion to David.
On the expression as your soul lives, see the discussion under 1 Sam 17.55; 20.3; and 25.26.
This thing: this probably refers back to the idea of returning home. But in some languages it may be more natural to say “these things,” referring to the details of eating, drinking, and having sex that are implied in the notion of going home.
Quoted with permission from Omanson, Roger L. and Ellington, John E. A Handbook on the First and Second Books of Samuel, Volume 2. (UBS Helps for Translators). New York: UBS, 2001. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.