Translation commentary on Mark 6:11

Text:

Instead of hos an topos mē dexētai ‘whatever place may not receive’ of all the modern editions of the Greek text, Textus Receptus has hosoi an mē dexōntai ‘whoever (pl.) may not receive.’

At the end of the verse Textus Receptus adds amēn legō humin, anektoteron estai Sodomois ē Gomorrois en hēmera kriseōs, ē tē polei ekeinē ‘Truly I tell you, it shall be more tolerable for Sodom or Gomorrha in the day of judgment, than for that city.’ All modern editions of the Greek text reject this addition which, for the sake of harmony, was introduced here from Mt. 10.15.

Exegesis:

os an topos mē dexētai humas ‘whatever place may not receive you’: the presumed meaning would be, ‘whatever town,’ or ‘whatever city.’ Manson, however, suggests that ‘place’ here probably refers to the synagogue as the place of worship where the disciples would naturally go to deliver their message. In the light of the following clause ‘nor should they hear you’ this conjecture is reasonable.

dechomai (9.37; 10.15) ‘receive,’ ‘accept,’ ‘welcome’; ‘receive as guest.’

ekporeuomenoi (cf. 1.5) ‘going out,’ ‘leaving’: this participle probably should not be understood as temporal ‘when you go out’ (Revised Standard Version) but in light of the imperative mode of the principal verb ‘shake off,’ should be translated as an imperative ‘go out!’ ‘leave!’

ektinaxate ton choun ton hupokatō tōn podōn humōn eis marturion autois ‘shake off the dust which is under your feet as a testimony to them’: cf. Acts 13.51, 18.6, for examples of this practice.

ektinassō (only here in Mark) ‘shake off.’

chous (only here in Mark) ‘dust,’ ‘dirt.’

eis marturion autois (cf. 1.44) ‘as a testimony to them’ probably in a hostile sense ‘against them’ (Revised Standard Version), though Taylor objects (Translator’s New Testament ‘to them’); autois ‘them’ refers to the citizens of the town.

Translation:

Any place must in many instances be ‘the people of any place’ (‘town’ or ‘synagogue’).

Receive is in some languages ‘to welcome’ or ‘to let you enter their town’ or ‘to say, Welcome’ (Cashibo-Cacataibo), or ‘to respect,’ literally, ‘to consider big’ (Tzeltal).

Refuse to hear is translatable as ‘will not listen to.’

Testimony against them (or possibly ‘to,’ see above) is rendered in a number of ways, for this context does not employ the Greek term marturion ‘witness’ in the more usual sense. Some of the ways in which this expression may be translated are ‘in order to show them what they have done’ (Navajo), ‘that shall become a testimony in their eyes’ (Tzeltal), ‘a sign, that witnesses to their guilt’ (Toraja-Sa’dan), ‘to show that they are responsible’ (Barrow Eskimo), and ‘so that it will be known about them’ (Central Mazahua).

For translators who follow Textus Receptus, there are added complications in the comparative expression more tolerable for, which is rendered variously in different languages (for a discussion of some comparative expressions see 1.7). More tolerable for is often translated as ‘the people of Sodom and Gomorrha will suffer less than the people of that city.’ In some instances one must use a double expression, e.g. ‘that city will suffer much, Sodom and Gomorrha will suffer little’ (Chol). Some languages employ an idiom meaning ‘to surpass,’ e.g. ‘the people of that city will surpass in suffering what the people of Sodom and Gomorrha suffer.’

Day of judgment may be rendered as ‘day when God judges’ or ‘day when God will say people have sin’ (Tzotzil), or ‘day when people will be judged.’

Note that in many instances one cannot speak of ‘a city suffering,’ but only of ‘the people of a city suffering.’

Quoted with permission from Bratcher, Robert G. and Nida, Eugene A. A Handbook on the Gospel of Mark. (UBS Handbook Series). New York: UBS, 1961. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

SIL Translator's Notes on Mark 6:11

6:11

Some Greek manuscripts have an extra sentence at the end of 6:11. The King James Version follows these manuscripts and adds the following:

Verily I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for Sodom and Gomorrha in the day of judgment, than for that city.

Many of the older Greek manuscripts do not include this sentence, and most English versions do not include it. The sentence is in Matthew 10:15, and scholars believe someone added it later to the parallel passage here in Mark 6:11. It is recommended that you should not include this sentence in your translation.

6:11a

And if any place will not welcome you: The clause will not welcome you means that nobody in the town invited the disciples to stay in their home. Also, nobody did anything to show the disciples that they wanted them to be in their town.

or listen to you: The clause listen to you refers to the people of a particular place refusing to listen to the disciples’ message.

6:11b

shake the dust off your feet when you leave that place: Here Jesus told the disciples to remove or shake off any dust that was sticking to their feet and sandals. They probably did this by shaking their feet or brushing off the dust with their hands. Consider how you would describe this kind of action in your language.

Shaking the dust off their feet was a cultural gesture that had a symbolic meaning. When a Jewish person shook the dust of a place off of his feet, it indicated that he did not have any relationship with the people in that place. It implied that the people were not God’s people. In this context, it meant that the disciples were no longer responsible for what happened to those people. God would punish the people because they did not accept the disciples and their message. The people would cause their own punishment, because they refused the message.

It is important to translate this gesture literally here in 6:11b. Then you can explain the meaning in the next phrase (6:11c).

Here are some other ways to translate this:

shake off the dust from the bottom of your feet when you leave
-or-
when you leave, shake/brush/tap your feet to remove the dust

your feet: If your language has specific words for the “lower leg and foot” or for the “sole of the foot,” you may use either of these expressions.

6:11c

as a testimony against them: The phrase as a testimony against them gives the meaning of the symbol of shaking dust off one’s feet. When the apostles shook off the dust of a town from their feet, they were warning the people. They were saying that God would judge them if they did not repent.

Here are some other ways to translate this phrase:

as a warning to them that God will judge/punish them
-or-
as a sign to show them that they are responsible/guilty

© 2008 by SIL International®

Made available under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 License (CC BY-SA) creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0

All Scripture quotations in this publication, unless otherwise indicated, are from The Holy Bible, Berean Standard Bible.
BSB is produced in cooperation with Bible Hub, Discovery Bible, OpenBible.com, and the Berean Bible Translation Committee.