Translation commentary on Ruth 1:12: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

Here again Naomi’s words are far too blunt, when translated literally, to have been spoken to her daughters-in-law, unless she intended to insult them! The overt reference to her bearing children (which they had not) and the implicit mention of sexual intercourse (despite the euphemism: to “have a husband this night”) are particularly troublesome from the point of view of Chewa/Tonga verbal etiquette. Naomi sounds as if she is despising her daughters-in-law.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 169.

Translation commentary on Ruth 1:11: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

Naomi’s apparent suggestion that she might bear more sons for her daughters-in-law to marry sounds crudely out of place in a Tonga setting. Surely there would have been some near kinsmen available who could have performed this vital socioreligious function, e.g., an uncle or cousin of the deceased (from the mother’s side of the family).

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 169.

Translation commentary on Ruth 1:9: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

Adults, whether of the same or the opposite sex, do not kiss one another publicly in traditional African society. A mother, however, may affectionately kiss her small child or baby. One must therefore indicate the social significance of this act in the original; e.g., “she bid them farewell by kissing them.” The reason for the daughters’ “weeping” is also not clear from the text. Loud public crying or wailing is normally done only at the time of a funeral.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 169.

Translation commentary on Ruth 1:8: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

The literal form of Naomi’s suggestion turns out to be very misleading in both Chewa and Tonga (it is somewhat problematic culturally in Hebrew as well; see the commentaries). It would be a grave insult indeed to tell a girl to “go back home and stay with your mother” (Good News Bible), for this would imply that she has failed somehow as a wife and needs to be sent back to her village in order to receive further domestic “training.” In fact, the marriage would probably end there. In this situation there is the added complication that Naomi seems to be acting contrary to custom by refusing to allow her widowed daughters-in-law to be married again to close relatives of the clan of the deceased (i.e., her own sons). Other possible negative implications are that Naomi is here verbally abusing her daughters-in-law (after luring them away from their village) because they had not been properly married to her sons, or worse, that Naomi did not want them along since she suspected them of being “witches”; for what other reason should her husband and only sons die in that foreign land? Her subsequent words would then be taken ironically—a curse in the form of a blessing: may God do to you as you have done to my two sons and me myself (i.e., through my husband — you and your people have killed them all off!).

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 168f.

Translation commentary on Ruth 1:6: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

For the Tonga, who are patrilocal and practice the custom of giving “bridewealth” (lobola) whereby the wife’s clan is “compensated” for her physical loss to the group, it is normal to hear that Ruth and Orpah were going to accompany Naomi on her return to her homeland. There they would be married to the near relatives of their deceased husbands. If they had refused to go along, their fathers would be compelled to return the bridewealth, especially since these marriages had not really been “established,” as there were apparently no children involved in either case. This situation would not be as customary among the Chewa, who are matrilocal (at least during the early years of a marriage) and who do not observe the bridewealth tradition.

While it is normal to attribute the “giving of food” to God, it would be most unusual to hear that he had “visited his people.”
According to traditional belief, God lives, estranged from man, far away in the sky. The Hebrew verb in this context refers to Yahweh’s gracious care for his people; i.e., he “blessed” them “by giving them good crops” (Good News Bible).

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 168.

Translation commentary on Ruth 1:4: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

It is somewhat of a surprise to hear that both of Elimelech’s sons married foreign women. It would have been expected that arrangements be made to have at least one of them marry a girl from “back home,” especially in the case where the family still clearly regarded Bethlehem in Judah as the place where they ultimately belonged (1:19,22). They had not even resided in the land of Moab all that long, i.e., ten years at the maximum. It is no doubt true to say that cross-tribal marriages were not the norm for the people of Judah either, at least not among those who took their religion seriously, but then again, the receptor would probably not know that information. There are many reasons why intertribal marriages are generally frowned upon by the Tonga, for example. Social and religious factors are especially prominent, e.g., differences in liminal customs at birth, maturation, marriage, and death; diverse religious practices, such as how to sacrifice and to whom (which ancestors); and so forth.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 167.

Translation commentary on Ruth 1:2: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

A family (clan) might well move to a different location at a time of prolonged drought (= famine in Central Africa) or when the ground/range was depleted. But in the past it would be unusual for them to travel out of the area of their particular ethnic group (which might include some closely related tribes, e.g., the Tonga, IIa, and Lenje of south-central Zambia). Thus Elimelech’s action of transfer-ring his family from Judah to Moab (i.e. outside of the land of the “twelve tribes”) is atypical from an African perspective. A man might go off to work in a “foreign” place in order to earn some hard cash, but then he would generally travel alone, leaving his wife and children behind.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 167.

Translation commentary on Ruth 1:1: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

It sounds rather strange right at the beginning to hear that “judges ruled” in the land of Judah. Traditionally the position of “judge” was not all that important in the Central African community, for it was the diviner who usually determined the question of guilt and innocence. It might be that subsequently the council of “elders” would decide what penalty ought to be meted out in the case of offenders. Even later in colonial history, when government-appointed official judges came on the scene, such men were never viewed as functioning in any capacity of administrative rule, for this work was being done by others. Part of the problem, of course, arises with the English translation itself. The Hebrew shophetim is in many contexts better rendered as “deliverers”; they acted more in the capacity of military leaders than as judicial arbiters. They would correspond to the paramount chief of certain African peoples, particularly those with a strong military tradition.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 166f.

For more of the “Ruth in Central Africa” series, see here.