Translation commentary on Ruth 2:9: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

“Young men” do not normally “draw water” in an African context, certainly not for any women who might happen to be present. Boaz’ rhetorical question of assertion, “Have I not charged the young men not to molest you,” has to be transformed into a direct statement so that its illocutionary force will not be misunderstood.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 174.

Translation commentary on Ruth 2:8: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

In a Chewa/Tonga setting Boaz could not address Ruth as “My daughter” (which turns out to be “my child” in Chichewa/Chitonga) unless he happened to be very much older than she was. He would rather say “mother” (mai, i.e., moderate respect, versus the ultimate honorific, “mothers”). Neither could he refer to his laborers as “my maidens,” for in Chitonga this could be interpreted as meaning his girlfriends. Instead he would use “female workers” and omit the “my.”

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 174.

Translation commentary on Ruth 2:7: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

As the workers report to Boaz about Ruth’s industriousness, they emphasize the fact that “She . . . worked steadily . . . except for a short rest in the shelter.” This was rendered by an idiomatic expression in the old Chichewa Bible, ‘in the house she doesn’t stay long,’ but this means something quite different. In a culture where a woman’s place is definitely in the “home,” it suggests that Ruth is some sort of busybody, or worse, of immoral character.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 173f.

Translation commentary on Ruth 2:6: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

The double reference to Ruth’s country of origin is somewhat awkward stylistically, especially in direct discourse. There does, however, seem to be a special emphasis on “Moab” in the book, and therefore the foregrounding effect of the repetition ought to be retained, if possible, in the translation (cp. also 1:6, 22). In this passage the reiteration also serves to stress Ruth’s foreign origin.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 173.

Translation commentary on Ruth 2:5: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

A literal translation of Boaz’ question, “Whose maiden (young woman — New American Standard Bible) is this?” would be very inappropriate in Chichewa, for it suggests that he is asking about whom she is married to (with an ulterior motive in mind). He would have to say, “Who is this lady?” (i.e., the assumption being that she is married, but the term used is one of respect).

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 173.

Translation commentary on Ruth 2:4: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

Boaz’ words of greeting to his workers (“The Lord be with you!”) and their reply to him (“The Lord bless you!”) have a distinctly liturgical ring about them. They make Boaz sound like the local parish pastor or priest. These were conventional formulas of welcome in Hebrew, but their formal correspondents fit into an entirely different speech register in many receptor languages. By replacing them with local equivalents in the receptor language, however, such as “You are seen, clansmen” . . . “Yes, we are seen” (Chitonga), would eliminate an essential religious component that probably ought to be retained in this story. The wish that God would “be with” a person is conceptually difficult for two reasons. As has been noted, according to traditional belief, God is regarded as living far away from man, personally and psychologically, with no real desire to come any closer (although in times of calamity he may be cajoled into helping by means of prayers and offerings). Secondly, the reason for inviting his immediate presence is not readily apparent. The meaning must there-fore be clarified with an expression such as “May God be good-hearted (i.e., favorable) to you” (Chichewa).

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 172f.

Translation commentary on Ruth 2:3: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

The Chewa have a similar custom to the one mentioned here (cf. Lev. 19:9-10), that is, the poor of the community are allowed to go into the field of a wealthy farmer after the harvest to gather what has been left behind (i.e., to “glean”). People of lesser means, however, make sure they get all of the grain (usually maize) out of the field the first time through.

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 172.

Translation commentary on Ruth 2:2: A Cultural Commentary for Central Africa

Instead of replying, “Go, my child,” to Ruth’s request, Naomi would have sounded more idiomatic in Chichewa by saying, “Alright, mother” (Chabwino, amai). The first word indicates her agreement with the request, the appellation shows her respect for her daughter-in-law. The use of personal names is completely taboo in such face-to-face dialogues (cp. Good News Bible — Naomi: “Now be patient, Ruth” (3:18). The relations between in-laws in a traditional environment are kept in an intricate social balance by an established set of status markers and terms of avoidance. This may be a minor stylistic matter, but when violations are compounded, especially in direct speech, it immediately brands the translation as being linguistically foreign.

There is also a problem of implication with the words ” . . . glean . . . after him in whose sight I shall find favor” (RSV). This would indicate that Ruth already had a specific person in mind. Thus the reference must be generalized; e.g., Good News Bible: “I am sure to find someone who . . . .”

Source: Wendland 1987, p. 172.